A letter to my MP, dated 1 Feb 2005
Hi
As the owner of a Ltd company, was surprised when my accountant recently wrote to me about "Tax Fee Insurance". This seems to be a new tax on honest businesses that file on time and have accounts in order and seems to be a new way for the inland revenue to scam honest businesses out of possibly thousands of pounds, just because they are unlucky in the Inland Revenue lottery.
How it works:
1. The inland revenue encourages people to do self assessment and file online. This puts the donkey work onto ordinary people, thereby freeing up resources in the Inland Revenue for random checks.
2. As a result, more random checks are done and the figures I have is that this is now about 1 business in 10.
3. As a result of an "Aspect" or "Full" enquiry randomly selected businesses are investigated once they have filled in their annual accounts, even though there may be no suspicion of anything wrong, it is simply a random audit.
4. My accountant, who prepares the accounts has to get involved.
5. My accountant then bills me for the time they spent talking to the Inland Revenue on my behalf. Accountants are not cheap and £100 an hour is at the lower end of what they charge.
6. Accountant then presents me with a bill for several hundred or possibly thousands of pounds which I have to pay, even though it was the Inland Revenue who requested the time and work.
7. I am then several hundred or thousand pounds out of pocket even though I have done nothing wrong and my books are in order.
8. To protect me from this scam a new industry has sprung up offering "tax fee protection insurance". Rates are often £100-£120 a year and based on fixed annual renewal dates. So if you join a scheme in May and the renewal date is November, you still pay the full whack even though it's for only 6 months cover.
Can I suggest that this is hardly the spirit of enterprise and is a wholly unwelcome financial burden on small companies which are doing nothing wrong. It's random taxation.
My view is that these random audits are no bad thing, but if the Inland Revenue needs to do them, the Inland Revenue should pay. Has anyone ever tried taking them to the small claims court for this? Perhaps I could adopt the same tactic and bill the Inland Revenue for excessive time spent form filling, excessive bureaucracy, and so on. After all why should the small business have to keep forking out for dealing with Inland Revenue issues? How is this fair?
Note: Subsequent to writing the above I had the question raised in the House of Commons.
By Craig Cockburn, IT Professional from Scotland. Digital Transformation, Agile Management, Politics and Social change
Total Pageviews
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Popular Posts
-
An article on how Agile can sit alongside PRINCE2 and where DSDM Atern fits in. In 2007, I put "used an Agile/PRINCE2 development str...
-
Find me on LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/in/siliconglen/ Medium https://siliconglen.medium.com/ thanks Craig
-
BBC NEWS | Politics | £141m benefits computer shelved : "It is the latest in a long series of computer problems for the government....
-
Your profile indicates you have been contracting recently, therefore you will only be interested in contract work then? Incorrect. Thi...
-
The UK Government Digital Service (GDS) has just had a reboot . However will it be value for money and deliver its objectives? Will th...
-
Please visit this link . I used to run a PRINCE2 group on LinkedIn, but have now closed it (no point in duplication) Craig
-
I first promoted Demon in June 1992, the month they set up. I joined them as a customer the following year. This is the first time I have mo...
-
I typically get a lot of calls from Recruitment Agencies. Usually it's about 20-25 a week. At 5-10 mins a call plus the inevitable telep...
-
Another government IT disaster. 10 years behind schedule, the Dunblane gun register is 'unfit for purpose' . The article also mentio...
-
I find a good part of my lunch hour is spent dealing with fairly useless contact centres. I would probably get more out of my lunch break an...
No comments:
Post a Comment